Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard Judd's avatar

You're likely to have polite feedback as readers/fans of your output already. Whether though you'd get anything you'd realistically find of value out of this, that's up for debate!

Whatever you've written on Substack already from me at least gets a "Like" because it's always worth my time to read something. So for a book chapter, if I fed back and said "Rob, I enjoyed that chapter, the character is developing nicely and the plot's intriguing", how does that really help further?

Obviously we could point out typos which sometimes sneak in on occasions, but I for one don't feel I would be in a better position to influence anything when my book output is zero vs your 13 and a half, and we here at least enjoy your content already.

Expand full comment
Tim Lake's avatar

My only trepidation is if you slightly lose your own vision in trying to please the readers. One of the flaws of American TV is (or was, certainly) the way they air episodes while the series is still being produced. There have been many examples where they keep changing it to please the feedback and the show loses itself as a result.

I'm sure your readers are savvy and the feedback wouldn't be as much of an issue, but I do belive a novel should be your own vision, pure and unadulterated.

Expand full comment
16 more comments...

No posts